I asked 7 chefs about their favorite peanut butter and the winner was a total surprise

I asked 7 chefs about their favorite peanut butter and the winner was a total surprise

HomeCooking Tips, RecipesI asked 7 chefs about their favorite peanut butter and the winner was a total surprise

We didn't see this coming.

ChannelPublish DateThumbnail & View CountActions
Channel Avatar Nick DiGiovanni2023-12-23 17:00:22 Thumbnail
18,335,291 Views

Celebrities review my food

If you take a look through our recipe archives you’ll quickly discover that we here at Allrecipes are crazy about peanut butter. From the many ways to use peanut butter outside of sandwiches to the best peanut butter desserts (including Grandma’s!) we’ve got plenty of ways to enjoy the spread.

Last year we tested 11 peanut butter brands to find the best. The brand that won the 2023 Allrecipes Community Choice Awards took first place: Jif.

But when we recently asked a panel of professional chefs and cookbook authors Jif didn’t even get a mention. Instead six other brands came out on top. While we’ll always have a nostalgic preference for the brand picky moms choose after learning which peanut butter these culinary pros swear by—and why—we might be cheating.